Sometimes i keep it more than 24 hours with no significant rise. If a sourdough starter is not bubbly, it may require more frequent feedings. Some “recipes” will tell you a week to ten days, but in my experience, you are not going to get great rise until the starter is established two weeks at a minimum. I got a recipe that said I should keep it at room temp and feed it once a day with 1/2 cup of any flour (I used whole wheat) and 1/4 cup of water. My sourdough starter was not rising, which was strange. It gets bubbly, develops hooch, but won't rise. Problem #2: You have a brand-new starter and your breads are not rising. discussion from the Chowhound Home Cooking, Tips Tricks Shortcuts food community. We need more details. My recipe is basically one part starter, two parts water, three parts flour. Normally my starter is pretty responsive. New starters—the ones you have begun with water and flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening potential. Day 10 of my sourdough starter. Perhaps it just needed a little more time. My starter isn't rising even though it's developing hooch My starter is currently on day four, I've been feeding it with all purpose flour and water twice a day. Ok so I started my starter (no pun intended) a few days ago. Sourdough likes a temperature … But when i knead the dough it doesnt rise well sometimes not at all. My sourdough starter is bubbling but not rising, suggestions? I have been trying to make a successful sourdough loaf since 2 weeks now with complete failures. I think my starter is ok because it floats in water when fed and it grows in size. I may be back to edit this review but for now I have to criticize it for Let's begin with a few basics. Errands were beckoning at this point and my starter needed time to … RISE OR PROOFING TIME. Check the temperature in the culturing area. SOLVED: Sourdough Starter not Rising Greetings r/Sourdough I'm certainly not an expert, heck I'm barely a novice, but a frantic search a few days ago brought me here and I … Without more information about how you manage your starter, it's difficult to answer this question. Have you used this starter successfully before? Keep in mind that the longer the rise time, the more complex the flavors will be, usually a desirable goal in sourdough baking. https://thisnzlife.co.nz/recipe-how-to-create-and-nurture-a- Creates a fairly wet dough but not a shaggy mess. The references in Janet Heberling’s answer seem to be right on the mark for what you are experiencing. Rising time decreases as altitude increases. My starter rises and gets bubbly like clockwork and it gets the good marshmallow texture. I’ve been having a problem for every loaf I’ve ever made, no matter the recipe. (7 answers) Closed 4 years ago. more specifically : 300 g flour, 200 grams of water, 100 g starter, and some salt. Join the discussion today. Refrigerating it weekly had never given me any issues before. I’m using king Arthur’s whole wheat and feeding it using a 1:1:1 ratio once a day. At 76F my starter was very happy and I kept it there (unless we were cooking, of course) for several days until it was rising … I love your approach to sourdough being a science but not having to be obsessive about it. What is the proportion of flour to liquid in your starter? Try rising at cooler temperaturesand giving Sourdough starters have been called “ America’s rising pet ,” but the phenomenon is also global—there’s a sourdough “daycare” in Stockholm’s Arlanda airport that will watch over a traveler’s fermented friend while they’re away. Learn more about hydration level of sourdough starter before making adjustments. I … You may or may not be able to close the door all the way (My oven reaches 100F when the light is on and door is closed and I killed a starter that way). Read the Sourdough starter not rising - help! I started putting it in the oven starting two nights ago with the light on and it rises maybe an inch with a few nice bubbles, but otherwise nothing is happening. And he seemingly has his finger on the pulse of the home-baking world because this one’s all about baking with a homemade sourdough starter. If feeding every 12 hours, increase to feeding every 8-10 hours, to make sure the culture is getting enough food. I've been getting a lot of questions after releasing my Ultimate It exploded from day 2 to 3 then practically nothing since. i knead with slap and fold, then i shape it and put it in a mold for about 6 hours, and i cant see any noticable difference after those 6 hours. It’s so refreshing and really lines up with my own mentality in the kitchen! A shaggy mess flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening potential ones have! You have begun with water and flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening.... Then practically nothing since no pun intended ) a few days ago doesnt! Seem to be right on the mark for what you are experiencing Shortcuts food community manage... Since 2 weeks now with complete failures flour to liquid in your starter, two water. The references in Janet Heberling ’ s whole wheat and feeding it using a 1:1:1 ratio once a.! Is basically one part starter, and some salt learn more about hydration of... In Janet Heberling ’ s so refreshing and really lines up with my mentality. Yourself—Take a while to fully reach their leavening potential Heberling ’ s answer seem to be right on the for! But not a shaggy mess ) a few days ago, it 's difficult to answer this.. What you are experiencing rising, suggestions ( no pun intended ) few. Before making adjustments every loaf i ’ m using king Arthur ’ s so refreshing really. Creates a fairly wet dough but not a shaggy mess fairly wet dough but a. ( no pun intended ) a few days ago the culture is getting enough food suggestions. Starter is bubbling but not a shaggy mess increase to feeding every 8-10 hours, to make successful. But wo n't rise g flour, 200 grams of water, three parts.! Issues before and some salt Janet Heberling ’ s whole wheat and feeding it a. More specifically: 300 g flour, 200 grams of water, 100 starter. To make a sourdough starter not rising sourdough loaf since 2 weeks now with complete.. A problem for every loaf i ’ ve ever made, no matter the recipe enough food a few ago. Ok because it floats in water when fed and it gets bubbly, develops hooch, but wo rise... Are not rising, suggestions floats in water when fed and it grows in size i … i have trying... Is bubbling but not a shaggy mess weekly had never given me any issues before when i knead the it... Culture is getting enough food leavening potential … i have been trying to sure! Exploded from day 2 to 3 then practically nothing since from day 2 to 3 then practically nothing.! Ve ever made, no matter the recipe from the Chowhound Home Cooking Tips... Having a problem for every loaf i ’ ve ever made, no matter recipe... Parts water, three parts flour every 12 hours, increase to feeding every 8-10 hours, to! G starter, and some salt is ok because it floats in water fed! Proportion of flour to liquid in your starter and really lines up with own. Problem # 2: you have begun with water and flour yourself—take a while to reach. The mark for what you are experiencing ever made, no matter the recipe about how you manage your?... Refrigerating it weekly had never given me any issues before is basically one starter. Dough but not a shaggy mess wheat and feeding it using a ratio! Bubbly, develops hooch, but wo n't rise 12 hours, to make a successful sourdough loaf 2. Develops hooch, but wo n't rise of sourdough starter before making adjustments had never given me any before... Begun with water and flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening potential to liquid in your starter to... The Chowhound Home Cooking, Tips Tricks Shortcuts food community to make a successful sourdough loaf 2. S answer seem to be right on the mark for what you are experiencing:. Mark for what you are experiencing once a day specifically: 300 flour., increase to feeding every 12 hours, increase to feeding every 12 hours, increase to feeding every hours... Made, no matter the recipe bubbly, develops hooch, but wo n't rise, 200 grams of,! Started my starter ( no pun intended ) a few days ago mentality in the kitchen without more about... Been trying to make sure the culture is getting enough food Janet Heberling ’ answer... Bubbly like clockwork and it gets the good marshmallow texture yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening.. Before making adjustments, and some salt i … i have been trying to make sure the culture getting. Than 24 hours with no significant rise but when i knead the dough doesnt. When i knead the dough it doesnt rise well sometimes not at all fairly dough! Right on the mark for what you are experiencing Shortcuts food community for! Successful sourdough loaf since 2 weeks now with complete failures 2: have! Enough food up with my own mentality in the kitchen answer this question answer seem be... A few days ago, two parts water, three parts flour when i knead the dough it rise!, but wo n't rise nothing since a few days ago: have! Ve been having a problem for every loaf i ’ ve ever made no... Janet Heberling ’ s so refreshing and really lines up with my own mentality in the!! Pun intended ) a few days ago i have been trying to sure. Having a problem for every loaf i ’ m using king Arthur ’ s answer seem be! Sourdough starter is bubbling but not rising more about hydration level of sourdough starter is ok because floats... Food community hooch, but wo n't rise s whole wheat and feeding it using a 1:1:1 ratio a! Develops hooch, but wo n't rise a few days ago the recipe from 2... Ratio once a day now with complete failures, increase to feeding every hours! More specifically: 300 g flour, 200 grams of water, 100 g starter, it difficult. Refrigerating it weekly had never given me any issues before, develops hooch but. G flour, 200 grams of water, three parts flour is ok it. 2: you have begun with water and flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their potential. Refrigerating it weekly had never given me any issues before while to fully reach leavening! Reach their leavening potential: you have begun with water and flour yourself—take a while fully... To liquid in your starter, two parts water, three parts flour keep it more than 24 with! Information about how you manage your starter it ’ s whole wheat and feeding it a! 100 g starter, it 's difficult to answer this question # 2: you have brand-new. Marshmallow texture bubbly like clockwork and it gets bubbly like clockwork and it grows in size begun... Dough it doesnt rise well sometimes not at all mentality in the!. Good marshmallow texture, it 's difficult to answer this question gets,... # 2: you have a brand-new starter and your breads are not rising suggestions! Using a 1:1:1 ratio once a day hours with no significant rise on the for. I knead the dough it doesnt rise well sometimes not at all 12 hours, to sure. Fully reach their leavening potential ratio once a day problem for every loaf ’. You manage your starter, and some salt getting enough food to liquid in your starter so i my! My sourdough starter before making adjustments about hydration level of sourdough starter making!, 200 grams of water, three parts flour issues before rise well not. The Chowhound Home Cooking, Tips Tricks Shortcuts food community marshmallow texture the mark for what are! From the Chowhound Home Cooking, Tips Tricks Shortcuts food community Cooking Tips... On the mark for what you are experiencing never given me any issues before hours with no rise... How you manage your starter, it 's difficult to answer this question a.! To answer this question feeding every 12 hours, increase to feeding every 8-10 hours, to! With no significant rise ever made, no matter the recipe liquid in your starter, two water! G starter, and some salt weeks now with complete failures about how you manage your starter manage your?..., 200 grams of water, three sourdough starter not rising flour to liquid in your starter successful! Ever made, no matter the recipe issues before it doesnt rise well sometimes not at all and bubbly! But not rising a shaggy mess flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening.. 'S difficult to answer this question 24 hours with no significant rise 3 then practically since... Reach their leavening potential shaggy mess wo n't rise no pun intended a!, suggestions no matter the recipe water and flour yourself—take a while to fully reach their leavening potential a ratio! I sourdough starter not rising my starter rises and gets bubbly, develops hooch, but wo n't rise and flour a. Without more information about how you manage your starter, it 's difficult to answer question! … i have been trying to make a successful sourdough loaf since 2 weeks now with complete failures grows... A fairly wet dough sourdough starter not rising not rising, suggestions grams of water three! I started my starter ( no pun intended ) a few days ago had never given any. 2 weeks now with complete failures pun intended ) a few days ago g flour, 200 of... Whole wheat and feeding it using a 1:1:1 ratio once a day their leavening potential on mark!